This blog is about learning to understand all of our feelings and learning to consciously face, feel, and experience all of our feelings within the context of our own childhood.
Everything we become and everything that happens to us is connected to childhood. Not every victim becomes an abuser, but every abuser was once a victim of abuse. These are facts. Violence is not genetic; it’s learned.
https://sylvieshene.blogspot.com/2014/08/a-dance-to-freedom-book-reviews.html
M: Dearest Sylvie, I hope that your Holiday season was enjoyable. I have posted some links and definitions for Epiphany, since it's a word often misused and misunderstood.I came to the conclusion that your book and our recent friendship have been my own Epiphany in 2014. I can hardly wait to sit down and share my latest news with you in a long email.Thank you for being such a fantastic being! M
Sylvie: Dear M, thank you for your lovely message. I worked through the holidays, and as you could imagine, work was busy, and I am glad the holidays are over.
I am so glad my book and friendship have been helpful to you.
Sometimes I asked myself why I bothered working so hard to deliver my book/baby to the world, most people would rather have pretty seductive lies or half-disconnected truths articulated by charlatans that are more than happy to exploit them by telling them the pretty lies they like to hear than have the naked truth I expose in my book. Still, when I get a message like yours, I am reminded why: there are people out there who really want the naked truth and facts, and are desperate, like I once was, to hear it from someone else.
Talking about charlatans, do you know J B, the author of Sxxx Sxxxxxx? He is a charlatan from Canada. Someone told him about my book, and he reached out to me. He suggested that we exchange books and offered to write me a review. I sent him my book, and he sent me his. However, I could tell from his website that he was not real. Despite this, I gave him the chance anyway. I read two pages of his book and could tell he was full of BS, so I put it in the recycle bin, and, of course, I never heard from him.There are so many charlatans out there pretending to be healed, preaching to others, that it is sickening. He probably thought I was another phony like him, and that is why he contacted me, but from reading my book, he saw I was real and not someone pretending like him. Phony people always promote each other but feel threatened by real people like me, and they will do their best to repress the work of real, honest people. Our world is full of phony people and psychopaths who promote each other and kiss each other’s asses.
It’s been a long day, and I have to get ready for bed. I hope you too had a good holiday season.
Talk more soon, Sylvie
M: Blah, Blah, Blah... This is how I feel after reading the first phrases on his website.When there are too many unnecessary words fluffing the expression of feelings in a text, I feel dizzy.This guy probably loves hearing his own gymnastic, contorted brain preach his own truth.Is he honest about being dishonest? You know the answer since you've thrown away his book. I've never heard about him since I've never searched for a quick fix or so-called soul-shaping gurus.I don't need anyone to confirm or approve that I have a soul, and, as a matter of fact, a damn beautiful one!Ironically, my greatest oppressor and lifetime soul terrorist, my father, gave me your book; the ultimate accessible Tool that helps me heal myself and understand my life story once and for all, so I can move forward.Seriously, at this point in time, the last thing I need is an opportunistic and seductive dude's guidance to recruit my so-called ''lost soul''.I'm not lost.I'm hurting as hell, trying to free myself from this emotional prison as you wrote so well.The only things I need in these crucial times are silence, space, peace, rest, respect, and “privacy". He probably found you attractive in all your beauty and light. He thought you'd fall for his BS like many women in search of some form of recognition, appreciation, attention, from a man representing their own fathers or husbands or boyfriends, or lovers, or...Don't worry about giving him the benefit of the doubt; it's part of your journey, and since you have nothing to lose but everything to gain, you will encounter each and every one of these charlatans. Go girl! Feed your fire with their books and keep spreading REAL SOUL HEALING FOOD.
Sylvie: Dear M, thank you for your kind and encouraging words.I get a little discouraged sometimes by so many charlatans in this world and by the emotionally blind people who fall for their BS. And reading your words is a breath of fresh air.
"... and thought you'd fall for his BS like many women in search of some form of recognition, appreciation, attention, from a man representing their own fathers or husbands or boyfriends, or lovers," sooooooooo true!
M: The guy is a lawyer.These people mastered the art of using powerful words to impress and befog the minds of vulnerable beings to make money.And they do make good money.Most of them lose their soul through the judicial system that claims to serve the Truth.He probably found himself hollow after losing the romance he cared for.These guys are dangerous because they manipulate women with their poetic wordings and fool any starved feminine soul out there.I met a guy like him back in 2009 during a long trip to Florida.No other man has written so many love letters, poems, and odes to my feminine beauty. He showered me with gifts, emails, phone calls, and pictures, but I saw through him, and soon enough, I figured he was another Beauty Stealer.As long as I allowed him to access my heart and my vulnerable soul in search of a deep connection, he fed off me like a vulture and fueled his shallow existence with my presence.When the time came to get really serious and act on his pretty words, he collapsed.He needed me to feed his ego and give his existence a sense, but he couldn't create a genuine, authentic relationship day to day.He was an empty shell with a mouth full of fluff.The path to authenticity can be pretty challenging, as you know.
Sylvie: Yes, he used to be a lawyer, and I wish he had stayed a lawyer, because I am sure he was more authentic then than he is now. Now he is too invested in his illusions and enmeshed in the web he has woven for himself, making it nearly impossible to break free. He is probably going to die in this web and take many with him.
M: I always said that I have more respect for an asshole that fully acknowledges he's an asshole than an asshole who pretends he's a nice guy.Authenticity can have many faces as long as it is real and transparent.I have repeatedly found myself in situations with people who pretended to be something they weren't, and I always ended up having to set them straight.Why do these so-called spirited gurus have so much influence? I understand your web concept, and I can see it clearly with my fresh eyes as I read his website. I really can't feel any attraction to his writing. It sounds like another sect in disguise to me.
Sylvie: Dear M, it’s so lovely to read your written words. I had posted our conversation about charlatans on my blog, of course, using people’s initials. I kept everyone anonymous, but some of his Facebook followers might know who I am referring to and start questioning his authenticity, trying to save themselves from his web. Now I have to add your last words to the blog! :-) The reason people fall for these gurus is that they are still emotionally blind by the repressed emotions of the child they once were, and their seductive words are like medication that makes people feel better temporarily and superficially.
Georgina Emily King:I find all his posts really inspirational and not at all fake... am I missing something??? Sylvie Imelda Shene.He does a good talk, but has not done the real walk. He is one more charlatan in our world whose only inspiration he gives is to distract people from facing and feeling their own repression, by helping them feel better temporarily and superficially, like medication does, with his seductive words. The quote you shared by him the other day, I felt he was inspired to write it from reading my book, to make him sound authentic, but he is not. He is a big illusion. My eyes are wide open, and I recognize an illusion or a lie when I see it.
Georgina Emily KingI've been digesting what you said above.... are you happy to discuss this here openly? As it's about someone else?
Sylvie Imelda SheneI have discussed everything I had to say about him in my blog about charlatans and in my comment to you above, but if you have more questions, you are welcome to ask them in a private message or here as long you keep him anonymous by just using initials; the reason is not that I want to protect him, because he is a public figure, so he is open for criticisms from the public, but because I don’t want to deal with the backlash from his followers. People who fall for charismatic charlatans are still little children looking for a father/mother figure. These charlatans become their substitute father/mother, and like little children who cannot afford to see the truth about their parents, because they are dependent on them, they will deny the truth and defend the parents by attacking those who dare to speak the truth about their supposedly “loving” parents, so their followers will do the same. They can get very nasty to anyone who dares to remove the mask or the pretty veils of their gurus, standing in as their substitute mother/father figure, exploiting them just like their own parents once did. The only shaping this guy is doing is trying to shape his bank account by selling his BS and illusions to those still emotionally blind by the repressed emotions of the child they once were. I was looking for a quote, and I found one that I think relates here: cult leaders and charlatans use similar clichés to attract followers, just as politicians use them to win votes. "There is a good deal else that would not exist without 'poisonous pedagogy." It would be inconceivable, for example, for politicians mouthing empty cliches to attain the highest positions of power by democratic means. But since voters, who as children would normally have been capable of seeing through these clichés with the aid of their feelings, were specifically forbidden to do so in their early years, they lose this ability as adults. The capacity to experience the strong feelings of childhood and puberty (which are so often stifled by child-rearing methods, beatings, or even drugs) could provide the individual with an important means of orientation with which he or she could easily determine whether politicians are speaking from genuine experience or are merely parroting time-worn platitudes for the sake of manipulating voters. Our whole system of raising and educating children provides the power-hungry with a ready-made railway network they can use to reach the destination of their choice. They need only push the buttons that parents and educators have already installed. Alice Miller, “Thou Shalt Not Be Aware” p.20, also cited in “Concerning Forgiveness: The Liberating Experience of Painful Truth.”
Since reading the letter of one of the John of God's accusers, I can't rid myself of the itch to write another blog about it.
I have written in past blogs that charlatans promote each other, and Oprah is one of the biggest charlatans out there, using her big platform to promote charlatans.
Only emotionally blind people fall for this crap. It's so sad. It's amazing how society gives Oprah a free pass and doesn't call her on being a charlatan promoting other charlatans.
In the dictionary next to the word "manipulation" should be the picture of Oprah because without a doubt, she has mastered the art of "manipulation" to "perfection".
The words below the accuser of John of God wrote before she killed herself, are very true. Sadly, she never developed two healthy legs to stand alone -- on her own two feet.
"John of God, Prem Baba, Gê Marques, Ananda Joy, Edir Macedo, Marcos Feliciano, DeRose Father, DeRose son, all priests, pastors, bishops, spiritists, Hindus, Umbellists, Mormons, Baptists, Methodists, Jews, Muslims, Sufis, Taoists, my family, Marcelo Gayger, Jorge Berenguer, I do not know about their childhood and how they were raised in this world, but I know in my heart that EVERY BOY WAS BORN PURE and was abused, corrupted, bruised, castrated, forced to do things that he did not want to do, until they became, in their own way, manipulating tyrants (to a greater or lesser extent) who, by not controlling their own impulses, try to control who they consider being smore fragile and thus commit rape, pedophilia, various addictions ... I know, I feel, I have seen." I like her too, I know, feel, and see. She wrote her letter in Portuguese, and I translated the words above with the help of Google Translate If you know Portuguese, you can read her whole letter HERE. Does anyone want more proof that Oprah is a charlatan promoting charlatans?!
"US TV host Oprah Winfrey traveled to Brazil in 2013 to meet him, and witnessed him performing so-called "psychic surgery" at his clinic." Read the full article HERE
One of the residents in the community where I worked for nine and a half years, in 2013, she had foot surgery, and after work around 3pm, I stopped at her house to help her. She was watching the Oprah show promoting John of God and she too traveled to Brazil to see him. Seeing this resident fall for this crap. I just wanted to throw up... Charlatans are so Annoying, they keep themselves and everyone else in an endless vicious circle. Oprah Winfrey: This is when my ‘job ended’ and my ‘calling began.’ Her calling was to become a cult leader and a cult leader promoter! The cult business is very profitable!
We live in a World of Puppets and Puppeteers, and Oprah is a master puppeteer; she has the whole world exactly where she wants it to be and is cashing in on society's emotional blindness.
A MASTER MANIPULATOR MAKES A LIE BELIEVABLE BY MIXING A SMALL FRACTION OF THE TRUTH WITH A LARGE FRACTION OF LIES
This is Oprah!
Read my blog, Experienced Knowledge about my experience with emotional harassment in the workplace.
The poem you shared with me, don’t take me wrong! It’s beautiful, but it expresses a dependent love because a mature conscious adult can always survive without the love from others. We might be sad if someone we love leaves us, but we can always survive. Only children depend on the love from others to survive. When adults are dependent on someone else’s love for survival can become very dangerous and destructive. It’s just a poem, so no big deal! Still beautiful!
I checked X’s book on Amazon and read the preview. The moment I read the line that he decided to sit next to the man wearing a Rolex turned me off right way, it reminded of the dancers/prostitutes that instead of dancing/working would be standing at the entrance of Bourbon Street looking at men’s shoes, because they could tell by what shoes they were wearing, if they were rich or not, and then follow them into their tables and try to get as much money they could from them, even if they had to sell their bodies and soul to get to their money.
I am interested in what kind of soul people have and I look into their eyes, the soul’s window! Not into what they wear. Looks Likes he is just motivated by money! I like to help people free their souls and it doesn’t look like he is interested in no one’s soul. So no he doesn’t look like someone I would like to make a connection with.
During our chat, I shared that would be very hard to point the finger at the deep-seated trauma that might take place in past generations that are manifesting in A’s body now. The body never lies. It is trying to tell the truth in A’s body. Diet might help her condition, but I think what would help more than anything else is to pay attention and be honest with one’s feelings and be open and willing to explore our history and try to understand what A’s condition is trying to show everyone.
I don’t think I’m a little hard on X. It is what it is! Yes, I met him at the Ball and he didn’t try to make a connection with me! Why?! Because he didn’t see in me as a step on the ladder to financial success?!
His fiancé the same, she was friendly with me and we were supposed to meet for coffee, but she never followed through, why? Because she didn’t see someone in me that would help her advance in her career?!
The reality is: if I played along with the sociopaths in S and have written a book telling people what they like to hear, didn’t challenge them in any way, didn’t require them to look in the mirror to question themselves, they all most like would be supportive of me and probably write great reviews. They would not have come after me so viciously like they did to try to destroy me to silence me to protect their own lies and illusions.
Charlatans promote each other’s illusions and lies,that’s why the books of so many charlatans become best sellers. And I most likely would be doing very well financially NOW, but to me, true success is to be healthy, free, happy and most important have peace of mind.
It’s nothing wrong with wanting to succeed financially, but I like to succeed by telling people the truth and not what they like to hear and if I can’t make money speaking the truth I rather not make a lot of money at all. I don’t need a lot of money anyway! Having peace of mind is more important to me! I totally accept where he is and I wish him success with his book and I hope his wishes come true, but we have to be honest with ourselves, at least in private, and see the reality and don’t fall for the pretty seductive lies and illusions that pretty much everyone in our society is trying to sell us and shove down our throats.
Like I told my sister Elza at the airport in 2005 when I was coming back to America: Believe in lies and you will be surrounded by liars, and she is surrounded by people that tell her the pretty lies that she likes to hear and she is paying a high price for believing these lies. Most people in our society are like my sister Elza, they believe in pretty seductive lies and illusions and this is why the books of so many charlatans become best sellers and society is paying a very high price for believing the charlatans seductive lies and illusions.
I don’t expect everyone to gather the courage to let go of their masks in public and become real.
Being real in public is a risk, a risk I was willing to take. And I don’t expect everyone to take this risk, because you have to be ready to take such a dangerous risk.
I understand he is one of your friends and you like him and is in your best interest to be publicly supportive of him, but in private is important that you see his true motivations and the truth for what it is, because if you confuse illusions for reality you are just confusing yourself, especially A that is too young to distinguish illusions from reality and is looking to you and S for guidance.
Believing in lies and illusions will keep you all permanently living in a state of confusion and is not good for anyone’s health. This quote by Alice Miller could not be truer: “Children who are told the truth and are not brought up to tolerate lies and cruelty can develop as freely as a plant whose roots have not been attacked by pests (in our case, lies)”
It seems you keep falling for everyone’s illusions and it was, especially, very sad to see you fall for the illusion of Donald Trump.
Believing in lies and illusions is not good for our psychical and mental health and for society as a whole.
"He was born Wayne Walter Dyer in Detroit and grew up in a series of foster care homes. His father was an alcoholic who left the family when Dyer was 3.” Quote from the article in the link above. I didn’t know much about his childhood, but I am not one bit surprised to learn he was abandoned as a child. He escaped his pain with the aid of his sharp intellect to recycle and package the same old seductive lies and disconnected half-truths that have been passed down from generation to generation since the beginning of time, to numb his childhood pain. It helped him survive in his emotional prison for 75 years without becoming a violent criminal, and with his books numbed also millions of people from their own pain. He helped people survive in their emotional prisons but didn’t free them.
For years, I was distracted from feeling my own childhood pain by his books and Deepak’s books. I remember going to listen to him and Deepak in the nineties when they would come to Phoenix, Arizona, and I was totally hooked by their seductive, feel-good speeches; it was like taking a drug! I wasted so many years with these charlatans and the 12 steps! Sorry if charlatan is too complex a word, but that’s precisely what they are.
He was a cult leader, and the world is full of cult leaders like him that keep people numb and distracted from their own painful truths. They pass on to others their own unresolved childhood repression under the illusion of love.
I wrote in my book A Dance to Freedom, pages 126 and 127, “Ultimately, I realized that self-help books and 12-step programs offer a false hope at best. I’m convinced that people who put their faith in these types of things — or in psychologists, psychiatrists, or any cult leader for that matter — are avoiding the real causes of their problems and are just masking their symptoms instead. The seductiveness of the quick fixes offered by traditional treatments and therapies is very powerful, and even if they don’t work, they offer at least temporary relief from the fear and pain of our abused younger selves. In the best of cases, groups like Al-Anon can momentarily help people cope with unhealthy situations and survive another day inside their emotional prisons, but they can’t resolve people’s problems. Everyone I encountered in Al-Anon was just reenacting his or her childhood drama like everyone else. The unhealthy, cult-like devotion they invested in the group was actually getting in the way of their true happiness because the group was just filling in for their parents and keeping them blind to the truth. In an email to a reader, Alice Miller writes that “even smart people become stuck in confusion for years if the ‘healers’ demand from them the same as the parents did from the child: to stay blind, to forgive, to make amends, not to make troubles. The fear of the parents, stored up in the body, can make a person obedient and sick forever. I hope that you can overcome this fear by seeing through the hypocrisy of your helpers.”62 “It is a great mistake to imagine that one can resolve traumas in a symbolic fashion,” Alice Miller writes in The Drama of the Gifted Child. “If that were possible, poets, painters, and other artists would be able to resolve their pain through creativity. This is not the case, however. Creativity helps us channel the pain of trauma into symbolic acts; it doesn’t help us resolve it. If symbolic revenge for maltreatment received in childhood were effective, then dictators would eventually stop humiliating and torturing their fellow human beings. As long as they choose to deceive themselves about who really deserves their hatred, however, and as long as they go on feeding that hatred in symbolic form instead of experiencing and resolving it within the context of their own childhood, their hunger for revenge will remain insatiable.”63
The question to Alice Miller and her answer below came to mind:
Borut Petrovic Jesenovec: Human blindness to abuse can be astonishing. Even when confronted with their own obvious abuse, people still believe in the myth of being loved, and keep abusing their children (and children of others). How would you most effectively "open their eyes" to what they are doing? Is this possible at all?
Alice Miller: I can’t open the eyes of others; they will quickly close them again, and they don’t want to see – or they are afraid to see – the truth because they expect to be punished by their parents or by God who represents them. I can only open my own eyes and say what I am seeing. And sometimes people feel encouraged to open one eye or even both. They are then surprised that they were not punished, that they feel even relief since they have stopped betraying themselves.
An interview was given by Alice Miller to Borut Petrovic Jesenovec in July 2005
Monica's Facebook comment: Cannot, not agree with you. I would like to think he is different from Deepak and Osho type of illusionists, i.e., he was genuine and believed what he 'prescribed' in his books to help people, even though they were 'aspirins' not 'antibiotics', unlike money-making machines like Osho, Tony Robbins, Deepak, who exploit desperate human beings. Sylvie Imelda Shenethey used to be my favorite charlatans! I loved listening to them both! They were my medication for many years!!! They are essentially the same, selling an illusion, just packaged differently, and you might have just preferred his version. If Monica Chelagatsold his product knowing it was an illusion, that would be charlatanism and unforgivable. Sylvie Imelda Shene is a charlatan, even if he believes his own illusions and seductive lies, simply because people are fooled by their own seductive lies. It doesn't make them less of a fraud.
More comments from the sharing of this post on Facebook: Donald Warner Parker"Resolving childhood repression is the vaccine against the charlatans of the world who exploit those who are still emotionally blinded by the unresolved, repressed emotions of the children they once were." --Sylvie Imelda Shene quote from her book A Dance to Freedom: Your Guide to Liberation from Lies and Illusions, page 172 Sylvie Imelda Shene, Yes, Donald, resolving our childhood repression is the vaccine against the lies of the charlatans of the world who exploit those who are still emotionally blinded by the unresolved, repressed emotions of the child they once were. I have no doubt that if I had not resolved my childhood repression, I would not have survived the mob of psychopaths at my last job, attacking me with their lies and methodically orchestrated smear campaign to destroy me, so they could go on as usual with their pretty facades that hide their true evil selves. I can only imagine how many souls they have destroyed and murdered in their lifetime. I’m probably the only one they set out to conquer, and they were not able to. I guess they didn’t believe what I wrote in my book, and they were confident they could destroy me like all the people they had killed in their past who had confronted and challenged them. Also, read Gurus and Cults Leaders: How They Function To read more about my experiences with the mob of sociopaths or narcissists at my last job, read my blog, Experienced Knowledge.
In a world saturated with self-proclaimed gurus and quick-fix healers, it can be disheartening for those committed to genuine, often difficult, emotional work. This exchange—between an author and a reader who found truth in her work—explores the fatigue of encountering charlatans, the hollow allure of their “pretty lies,” and the quiet power of authentic connection. It’s a raw look at why real healing is often rejected, and why truth-tellers can feel so alone.
Part 1: A Reader’s Gratitude and an Author’s Weariness
M. writes:
Dearest Sylvie, I hope your holiday season was enjoyable. I’ve been reflecting on the word “epiphany”—a term often misused—and I realized your book and our friendship have been my true epiphany this year. I can’t wait to share my latest news with you soon. Thank you for being such a fantastic being.
Sylvie replies:
Dear M, thank you for your lovely message. I worked through the holidays, so I’m glad they’re over.
I’m deeply touched that my book and our friendship have been meaningful to you. Sometimes I wonder why I work so hard to deliver my “book-baby” to the world. Most people seem to prefer pretty, seductive lies—or half-disconnected truths spun by charlatans who happily tell them what they want to hear. They shy away from the naked truth I expose.
But when I receive a message like yours, I’m reminded why it matters: there are people out there who truly want the truth, who are desperate—as I once was—to hear it spoken plainly by someone else.
Part 2: The Charlatan’s Playbook—A Personal Encounter
Speaking of charlatans, have you heard of J.B., the Canadian author of Sxxx Sxxxxxx? Someone told him about my book, and he reached out, suggesting we exchange books and he’d write me a review. I sent mine; he sent his.
Even from his website, I sensed he wasn’t real—but I gave him a chance. After two pages, it was clear he was full of empty rhetoric. I recycled the book and, unsurprisingly, never heard from him again.
There are so many pretending to be healed while preaching to others. It’s sickening. He probably contacted me thinking I was another phony like him, but reading my work showed him I was real. Phony people promote each other, but they feel threatened by authenticity. They do their best to suppress honest work. Our world is full of phonies and psychopaths who prop each other up.
M. responds with fire:
“Blah, blah, blah…”—that’s what his website left me feeling. When words are contorted into fluff, they just dizzy me. This guy probably loves hearing his own gymnastic brain preach. Is he honestly dishonest? You already know; you tossed his book.
I’d never heard of him—I don’t search for quick fixes or soul-shaping gurus. I don’t need anyone to confirm I have a soul (a damn beautiful one, in fact!). Ironically, my greatest oppressor—my father—gave me your book. It became the ultimate tool to understand my story, heal myself, and move forward.
The last thing I need now is some opportunistic man trying to recruit my “lost soul.” I’m not lost. I’m hurting, trying to break free from this emotional prison you wrote so well about. What I need is silence, space, peace, rest, respect, and privacy.
He probably found you attractive in your light and thought you’d fall for his act—like many women searching for recognition from a man who mirrors their father, husband, or lover. Don’t worry about giving him the benefit of the doubt; it’s part of your journey. You have nothing to lose. Go, girl—feed your fire with their books and keep spreading real soul food.
Part 3: The Dangerous Allure of Empty Words
Sylvie:
Dear M, thank you for your kind and encouraging words. I sometimes get discouraged by the sheer number of charlatans and the emotionally blind who fall for them. Your words are a breath of fresh air.
And you’re right—he probably thought I’d fall for his act “like many women in search of recognition…” So true.
M. adds insight:
The guy is a lawyer. They master using powerful words to impress and befog vulnerable minds—and they make good money doing it. Many lose their souls in a system that claims to serve truth. He probably felt hollow after losing a romance he cared for.
Men like him are dangerous: they manipulate with poetic wording, fooling starved feminine souls. I met one in 2009—he showered me with love letters, poems, gifts, calls. But I saw through him. He was a “Beauty Stealer,” feeding on my presence to fuel his shallow existence. When it came time for a real, day-to-day relationship, he collapsed. An empty shell with a mouth full of fluff. The path to authenticity is challenging, as you know.
Sylvie reflects:
Yes, he was a lawyer. I almost wish he’d stayed one—he might have been more authentic then. Now he’s too invested in his illusions, enmeshed in the web he’s woven. He’ll likely die in that web and take many with him.
M. on realness:
I’ve always said I have more respect for an asshole who admits he’s an asshole than one who pretends to be a nice guy. Authenticity can wear many faces, as long as it’s real.
Why do these “spirited gurus” have so much influence? I understand your “web” concept—reading his site, I feel no attraction. It sounds like a sect in disguise.
Part 4: Why People Fall for the Illusion—And Defend It
Sylvie shares the public dimension:
Dear M, it’s lovely to read your words. I posted our conversation on my blog (using initials for anonymity). Some of his followers may recognize him and start questioning his authenticity—maybe saving themselves from his web. I’ll have to add your latest thoughts!
The reason people fall for these gurus is emotional blindness. Their seductive words act like medication: they make people feel better temporarily, masking the repressed pain of the child they once were.
A Follower’s Defense on Facebook:
Georgina: I find all his posts really inspirational and not at all fake… am I missing something???
Sylvie’s public reply:
He talks well but hasn’t done the real walk. He’s another charlatan whose “inspiration” distracts people from facing their own pain—offering temporary, superficial relief, like medication. The quote you shared the other day felt like it was inspired by my book, crafted to sound authentic. He’s a grand illusion. My eyes are wide open; I recognize a lie when I see one.
Georgina asks:
I’ve been digesting what you said… are you happy to discuss this here openly? As it’s about someone else?
Sylvie’s final word on the matter:
I’ve said all I need to in my blog and in my comment above. If you have more questions, feel free to ask here or in a private message—just keep him anonymous (use initials).
It’s not to protect him—public figures are open to criticism—but to avoid the backlash from his followers. People who fall for charismatic charlatans are like children looking for a parent figure. These gurus become substitute parents, and like dependent children, their followers cannot afford to see the truth. They will deny it and attack anyone who dares to remove the mask.
The only “shaping” he’s doing is shaping his bank account, selling illusions to those still blinded by their own repressed childhood emotions.
Closing Reflection
I was looking for a quote and found one that fits perfectly here:
"There is a good deal else that would not exist without 'poisonous pedagogy. It would be inconceivable, for example, for politicians mouthing empty cliches to attain the highest positions of power by democratic means. But since voters, who as children would normally have been capable of seeing through these clichés with the aid of their feelings, were specifically forbidden to do so in their early years, they lose this ability as adults. The capacity to experience the strong feelings of childhood and puberty (which are so often stifled by child-rearing methods, beatings, or even drugs) could provide the individual with an important means of orientation with which he or she could easily determine whether politicians are speaking from genuine experience or are merely parroting time-worn platitudes for the sake of manipulating voters. Our whole system of raising and educating children provides the power-hungry with a ready-made railway network they can use to reach the destination of their choice. They need only push the buttons that parents and educators have already installed." ---Alice Miller, “Thou Shalt Not Be Aware” p.20, also cited in “Concerning Forgiveness: The Liberating Experience of Painful Truth.
“Ultimately, I realized that self-help books and 12-step programs offer a false hope at best. I’m convinced that people who put their faith in these types of things — or in psychologists, psychiatrists, or any cult leader for that matter — are avoiding the real causes of their problems and are just masking their symptoms instead. The seductiveness of the quick fixes offered by traditional treatments and therapies is very powerful, and even if they don’t work, they offer at least temporary relief from the fear and pain of our abused younger selves.”
“In the best of cases, groups like Al-Anon can momentarily help people cope with unhealthy situations and survive another day inside their emotional prisons, but they can’t resolve people’s problems. Everyone I encountered in Al-Anon was just reenacting his or her childhood drama like everyone else. The unhealthy, cult-like devotion they invested in the group was actually getting in the way of their true happiness because the group was just filling in for their parents and keeping them blind to the truth.”
Alice Miller expressed it so clearly:
“Even smart people become stuck in confusion for years if the ‘healers’ demand from them the same as the parents did from the child: to stay blind, to forgive, to make amends, not to make troubles. The fear of the parents, stored up in the body, can make a person obedient and sick forever.”
She continues:
“It is a great mistake to imagine that one can resolve traumas in a symbolic fashion. If that were possible, poets, painters, and other artists would be able to resolve their pain through creativity. This is not the case… Creativity helps us channel the pain of trauma into symbolic acts; it doesn’t help us resolve it.”
If symbolic revenge truly worked, dictators and war criminals would be healed by their “art.” But as long as they deceive themselves about who really deserves their hatred — and refuse to feel that pain in the context of their own childhood — their thirst for destruction will remain insatiable.
Borut: Human blindness to abuse can be astonishing. Even when confronted with their own obvious abuse, people still believe in the myth of being loved, and keep abusing their children. How would you most effectively "open their eyes" to what they are doing? Is this possible at all?
Alice Miller: I can’t open the eyes of others; they will quickly close them again, and they don’t want to see – or they are afraid to see – the truth because they expect to be punished by their parents or by God who represents them. I can only open my own eyes and say what I am seeing. And sometimes people feel encouraged to open one eye or even both. They are then surprised that they were not punished, that they feel even relief since they have stopped betraying themselves.”